When it comes to live production, it’s not always easy to calculate a team’s return on investment. Availability, scheme fit and opportunity are not guaranteed, making it difficult to compare raw statistics to a player’s contract.
But if you want to look purely at how much the team is paying per unit of production, the math becomes pretty simple.
advertise
Take wide receiver, for example. When you divide a player’s hit cap in a given season by their receptions, it’s easy to determine the cost per catch.
No team embodies this contrast more than the Los Angeles Rams.
On one hand, the Rams’ Tutu Atwell (h/t Ian Hartitz) has the highest price per catch among NFL receivers in the 2025 class. The 26-year-old signed a one-year, $10 million contract last offseason and finished the year with six catches for 162 yards and a touchdown. That works out to $1.67 million per catch.
On the other hand, the Rams also have the highest value per catch in the league. According to Over The Cap, Puka Nacua leads the NFL with 129 catches this season but makes just $1,091,245. That means Nacua will cost the Rams just $7,984 per reception — which is impressive when you consider he’s a legitimate candidate for Offensive Player of the Year.
advertise
The contrast is even more stark when you factor in playing time: Atwell has played in just 10 games this season, while Nakua has played in 16.
It’s partly an indictment of the Rams’ decision to pay Atwell so much money, but also an indictment of head coach Sean McVay not even being interested in utilizing a downfield threat on offense.
While Atwell did catch a game-deciding 88-yard touchdown earlier in the year, his role in the offense diminished significantly down the stretch. He also performed well in the divisional round against the Chicago Bears, a decision McVay explained came down to his inability to contribute on special teams.
advertise
On the other side is Nakua, who has completely exceeded expectations for his fifth-round rookie contract. But that’s the beauty of finding diamonds in the rough late in the draft and seeing production ramp up. Don’t worry, Nacua will be getting a sizable contract extension soon – the Rams are reportedly prioritizing getting Nacua a new deal this offseason.
So while the Rams didn’t see a huge return on investment from Atwell’s contract, his lack of production was offset by Nakua’s cheap production. However, the Rams certainly wish they could allocate that $10 million elsewhere on the roster.
This article originally appeared on Rams Wire: Rams’ 2025 WR-per-catch values are the NFL’s best and worst
