LIVIGNO, Italy — It looks shocking and sounds even crueler.
For a country that rejoiced in Lindsey Vonn’s comeback story and uncharacteristic attempt to win an Olympic medal without an ACL in her left knee, her helpless cries of agony as she lay on her back and the mountains fell silent will be hard to erase from memory.
advertise
Downhill skiing is often breathtaking. Sometimes it’s scary. For the second time in nine days, images of an American sports heroine strapped to a wooden plank and loaded into a helicopter were stomach-churning.
But that’s sliding down a mountain at 80 miles an hour. That’s the risk Vonn took when he decided to compete in the Olympics nine days after tearing his ACL in another game in Switzerland. That’s what happens sometimes when you work hard at it.
Vaughn did just that.
We may never know for sure, but Vonn’s knees probably weren’t to blame for her fall just 13 seconds into the run. If anything, the chain of events that led to her collapse on Sunday began with an aggressive line turning into a curve, shifting all her weight to her right side — rather than her injured left leg. Instead, it was her right pole that tangled with the door, knocking her off balance and throwing her into the air, landing on her belly as she hit the snow, then sliding a few feet and landing on her back.
advertise
Just like that, it was over. Too bad.
Lindsey Vonn of the United States is shown on a big screen after a fall while competing in the women’s downhill race at the 2026 Winter Olympics in Cortina d’Ampezzo, Milan, on February 8, 2026 at the Torfaen Alpine Ski Center in Cortina d’Ampezzo. (Photo: Tiziana FABI/AFP via Getty Images)
(Tiziana Fabi via Getty Images)
Like clockwork, there will no doubt be critics who say Vaughan should not have attempted something so dangerous, so bold.
But Vaughn, 41, has lived a bold life all his life. She also knows more about what can happen on the slopes, both good and bad, than the rest of us combined.
She knew what was going to happen. She deserves this opportunity. Now, only she can answer whether the consequences for her body were worth it.
It’s none of our business.
Is it nauseating to watch the game in real time? certainly. But when we attend sporting events, especially the Winter Olympics, there’s no guarantee the experience will be discomfort-free.
advertise
Many of these sports are dangerous. Often, athletes make it look easy for them. Sometimes we take their tolerance for risk for granted.
But this one slapped us all in the face — not just because she was one of the most accomplished winter sports athletes in the world, but because her pain, as played out to millions on television, was deeply connected to our own sense of fear and mortality.
Yes, this injury will cast a shadow over this Olympics. How could it not be? What we watch on Sunday is not just a sports game, but a microcosm of life. At some point, no matter how invincible we feel, everything can change in an instant.
Vaughan has no doubt she can do it. Her training results are very good. She spent part of Saturday sparring with her critics on social media, exuding a confidence that made you realize she wasn’t just here to slide down the hill.
advertise
She gave it her all. Maybe not good for her.
Some will say this is all a delusion, that doctors should not have given her the green light and that she should have given up her place in the field to a younger, healthier American.
stop.
Are you really going to tell a legend of the sport, someone who just retired and almost immediately re-emerged as one of the best in the world, that she can’t have this opportunity? please.
I asked downhill skier Brian Bennett about this idea on Saturday after his final Olympic race.
“I don’t know how many times she won the Cortina,” he said. “She understands that. She’s obviously in a good position with her gear. If she can be consistent on a run… I don’t think she has to take a huge risk. It’s not like she has to do anything crazy special.”
advertise
Maybe one day, after her injury heals, Vonn will tell us if this was the price she paid. Now, we’re left with what we see on TV – what appears to be an all-time skiing prodigy trying desperately, maybe too hard, to win a race while the rest of us just want her to finish.
But it doesn’t matter how we feel.
Vaughn has fallen before, had his knees blown out, and has felt pain that few of us can. She knew it might happen again, but she tried anyway.
So she did. Who are we to guess?
