The debate over how the U.S. should regulate the potential market for tokenized stocks is heating up as Wall Street’s traditional financial (TradFi) firms clash with cryptocurrency executives over whether decentralized trading infrastructure should be treated the same as traditional exchanges, according to a report from HSBC on Monday.
Tokenization is the process of converting ownership of real-world assets—from stocks and bonds to real estate, private equity, and even art—into digital tokens recorded on a blockchain.
The bank noted that a recent discussion at the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission’s (SEC) Investor Advisory Committee revealed differences of opinion on how to regulate on-chain stock trading.
Reports indicate that TradFi giant Citadel Securities has been criticized by members of the cryptocurrency industry for pushing for a tougher stance on decentralized finance (DeFi). Scott Bauguess, Vice President of Global Regulatory Policy at Coinbase (COIN), advocates developing rules suitable for decentralized trading models.
As for regulators, SEC Chairman Paul Atkins reiterated the need for compliance pathways that still promote innovation, while Commissioner Carolyn Crenshaw expressed concerns about the risks associated with tokenized stocks.
Analysts Daragh Maher and Nishu Singla wrote that at the heart of this conflict is a 13-page letter from Citadel to the SEC, which argued that many DeFi trading protocols meet the definition of an exchange and should be regulated accordingly.
Citadel said broad exemptions for DeFi could encourage regulatory arbitrage and create a “shadow market” where investor protections are weaker than in traditional venues.
Analysts say the SEC’s ultimate boundaries remain unclear.
Analysts said that while Atkins sees tokenization as part of modernizing U.S. capital markets, the agency is unlikely to allow U.S.-facing on-chain stock markets to operate under stricter protections than traditional exchanges.
One possible tool, the bank said, is a “sandbox” approach that would allow tokenized equity platforms to operate under restricted conditions while regulators test boundaries, particularly for U.S.-facing activities and identifiable teams.
HSBC said that over time, regulatory pressure may favor tokenized stock trading on a fully permissioned, fully regulated blockchain.
Nonetheless, the report adds that there is one broad point of agreement among TradFi, DeFi and regulators: tokenization is expected to grow from a smaller base, and the intensity of the current fight is itself a signal that the stakes are rising rapidly.
Read more: Bernstein says U.S. cryptocurrency framework positions country as global leader
