Whispers around the potential Giannis Antetokounmpo Trades have heated up in recent days, naturally pushing the Knicks — now 15-7 and having won seven of their last 10 games — into the rumor mill.
The basketball mecca is reportedly at the top of the perennial MVP candidate’s top list, so if the Knicks come up with their best offer, they should have a fair shot at acquiring the star. The question is, should they?
advertise
Reasons to trade Giannis
Despite seven different championships in seven different seasons, one thing remains constant about the modern NBA championship: employing a generation of superstars. Although now Jaylen Brunson Antetokounmpo deserves every superlative in the book, including an MVP candidate, and he is undoubtedly on another level of greatness.
For reference, over the past seven seasons, Giannis averaged 29.9 points, 11.8 rebounds and 6 assists per game while shooting 57.7% from the field. He was having an even better start to the year before the injury.
He was just five seasons away from winning an NBA championship and Finals MVP, and one year away from winning back-to-back MVPs. Without other up-and-comers and the Bucks’ roster slowly falling apart around him, he’ll have even more hardware.
advertise
So it’s easy to imagine this peak Shaq-esque production taking place in a modified environment without too many complaints about the cost. care about loss Karl Anthony Towns You need to replace him with an equally threatening scorer who cares about losing. Og Anunoby You replaced him with another Defensive Player of the Year front-runner.
A trade for Giannis would likely cost two of those players or other key rotation players, as well as draft capital, a foreseeable and necessary pill to pair him with Brunson. Doing this will maximize your championship cap, which is the ultimate goal of this competition Leon Rose New York Times.
Concerns about filling out the rest of the roster could be addressed before the trade deadline, with calls for current fringe rotation players to step up. Last year’s Thunder had impressive depth amassed through years of tanking and trading, an anomaly — recent champions have been honed through core eight-man rotations.
Those worried about Antetokounmpo’s ability to mesh with smaller defenders at the end of the game Damian Lillard The combination’s breakout should note that Brunson is younger and better at screening and off-ball threats. Lillard still needed a year to adjust to his new surroundings, and the Bucks made a midseason firing in an attempt to turn things around.
advertise
The Knicks have a stronger foundation to build a winner around Brunson and Antetokounmpo, and even their misfit assets are valuable enough to trade if needed. You can be picky as hell with your conditioning and asset management, or you can trade for top-five talent in the league and live with the results.
Milwaukee Bucks forward Giannis Antetokounmpo (34) dribbles while New York Knicks guard Josh Hart (3) defends during the second half at Madison Square Garden/Vincent Carchietta – Imagn Images
The case against trading Giannis
Unfortunately, concerns about Antetokounmpo’s health are more than just nitpicking. Almost any change to this deal, short of moving Brunson, would leave more basketball questions than answers.
Trading Towns leaves New York’s center rotation in trouble Mitchell Robinson, Ariel Hookboty and Trey Jemison III. Aside from their overall talent, none of them can space the floor for Giannis Antetokounmpo, who has long been a must-have in his frontcourt partner.
advertise
Antetokounmpo has never spent more time at the five than he needed to in his youth, and now that he’s over 30, he probably doesn’t want to do much more. Assuming it’s Towns and a wing, you could trade one of those players Josh Hart or Mikal Bridges The five-man unit can help the starters become more fluid, but after all of this movement, it’s impossible to ignore how thin the rotation is.
If the Knicks traded “Wingstop” for Antetokounmpo and managed to keep Towns, they would have a similar glut on the wings and be forced to rely on their guard Hart. Kyle Kuzma, Mohamed Diawara And everything that could come from a Robinson trade. Even if that issue is resolved, on-court chemistry may take longer to materialize than one might expect.
Towns hasn’t found his full rhythm yet Mike Brown No offense yet. What if there was a second alpha in front of him on the touch ladder? Defensively, can he still dominate in the playoffs without the team’s strong defensive depth?
Brunson Antetokounmpo’s problem goes beyond just superficial neglect of Lillard. Antetokounmpo takes the title with two big guards chris middleton and Jrue Holliday He ran a lot of pick-and-rolls as a ball-handler and screener.
advertise
Even if Brunson has ability off the ball, it’s unclear if he can replicate that formula, especially when his size crowds the screen and throws tough passes to Giannis Antetokounmpo. These are also relatively low-usage guards who can be at Giannis’ beck and call at all times, while Brunson, while flexible, primarily needs his hands on the ball.
In the end, the cost of the trade will eat into the Knicks’ chances to win now and in the future, with only a small impact on their championship ceiling. The Spurs and any team with similar assets are ready to ship out Giannis, and in order to match New York, they would have to give up any remaining scraps of their draft capital and rotational depth.
You’re bound to succeed in doing so, and while Antetokounmpo is as close as you’d think, he’s already 31, has a series of injuries on his resume, and will have plenty of questions to answer once he arrives. That doesn’t even take into account the opportunity cost of such a deal.
The Knicks are currently the favorite in the Eastern Conference, and few of their opponents have the ability to trade Antetokounmpo. That means New York can sit back, count its wins, watch as he potentially leaves the league, and only have to worry about some teams that fell out of the playoff picture a few years ago.
advertise
Why sacrifice that, and this impressive core, in a blockbuster midseason trade? The Knicks are in scramble mode, not desperation mode, and this move smacks more of the latter than the former.
