New Target policy makes some shoppers uncomfortable

As someone who has worked in the retail industry for over a decade, I can tell you that if there is one aspect of the shopping process that consumers are most confused about, it’s self-checkout.

Introverts like me may prefer having their items scanned rather than having to engage in awkward small talk with well-meaning store employees.

But for many shoppers, self-checkout is a step in the wrong direction. Instead, they prefer to interact with store employees and not just at the checkout.

Citing data from Sensormatic Solutions, Retail Dive reports that 64% of consumers prefer to interact with store associates. According to a recent x-hoppers survey, 60% of shoppers are willing to travel long distances to a store with friendly staff.

In light of this, Target has made some policy changes to encourage friendlier interactions between store associates and shoppers. But the results have been mixed.

As retailers increasingly use technology to get people in and out of stores faster, it’s important to focus on the human element.

“As we become more automated, it’s really important to have that personal touch, that personal connection,” shopping expert Trae Bodge told Today.

RELATED: Shoppers object to grocery giant’s new anti-theft measures

Target seems to be doing just that. The struggling retailer recently implemented a new 10-4 policy, USA Today reported.

See also  Warren Buffett’s 12 Easy Money Tips That Can Work for Anyone

Here’s how it works:

  • The target employee belongs to 10 feet Customers must smile, make eye contact, wave and use welcoming body language.

  • The target employee belongs to four feet of customers must personally greet shoppers, smile and offer to help.

“We know that when our guests are welcomed, feel welcome and get the help they need, that help translates into guest love and loyalty,” Adrienne Costanzo, Target’s executive vice president and chief store officer, told USA TODAY.

Not every Target customer wants to interact with an employee. Shutterstock
Not every Target customer wants to interact with an employee. Shutterstock · Shutterstock

At this point, Target needs to make some big changes to avoid a financial free fall. In its most recent quarter, Target reported a 1.5% increase in annual net sales and a 3.8% decline in comparable sales. Operating income fell 18.9% year-on-year.

But forcing employees to interact with customers may not be the perfect solution to regaining shopper loyalty.

In fact, some Target shoppers took to Reddit to express their displeasure with the new policy.

“Please don’t do this. I will make sure I’m not within 4 feet of any employee any time I spend at Target,” one user wrote.

Another said: “I understand there is a culture of kindness but this is too much.”

RELATED: Costco makes big changes to its bakeries

Target employees also expressed their thoughts on the new policy in a separate Reddit post.

See also  TradFi giant EquiLend backs Digital Prime to link $40 trillion pool with tokenized markets

“We’ve all entered the age of creepy smiles,” one person said. Another, meanwhile, accused Target of creating a work culture where employees aren’t content with being friendly.

“If your employees aren’t smiling at guests, it’s probably because your employees are extremely unhappy. If you fix the things that make your employees happy, you probably don’t need to announce a new program that enforces happiness,” the user said.

Related: Target’s History: Company Timeline and Facts

Target needs to make big changes to lure shoppers back. Target traffic fell 2.7% in the third quarter of 2025, according to Placer.ai.

But the reality is that employee friendliness, or lack thereof, isn’t the biggest driver of Target’s massive divestment.

More retail:

Instead, Target faces a series of challenges that need to be addressed quickly, including store confusion and inventory inconsistencies. There’s also the fact that consumers are cutting back on discretionary spending in response to ongoing inflation.

While Target’s friendly gesture is a step in the right direction, the reality is that the company needs to do many, many things to win back customers.

Maurie Backman owns shares of Target.

RELATED: Target sees shift in consumer behavior

This article was originally published by TheStreet on February 3, 2026, and first appeared in the Retail section. Click here to add TheStreet as your preferred source.

See also  Court jails man who killed Russian chemical weapons chief at Ukraine's behest for life

Spread the love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *