For many enthusiasts, it takes a lot of confidence to hand over a beloved classic to a restoration shop. In Galveston County, Texas, that trust turned into a years-long nightmare for dozens of car owners.
Richard Thomas Finley, the former operator of Classic American Street Rods in the St. Leon-Buckliff area, was sentenced to 60 years in prison for felony theft of more than $300,000. Prosecutors said Finley defrauded at least 72 victims between 2018 and 2023, collecting large advance payments for engine replacements that were never completed. The total amount stolen was more than $498,000, according to the Galveston County District Attorney’s Office.
Promised upgrades, delayed delivery
Finley reportedly marketed his business as a solution for classic car owners looking to modernize their vehicles. He offers “engine swaps” designed to replace aging powerplants with newer, more reliable, lower-maintenance options.
Clients are required to pay a substantial deposit before work can begin. What followed was a series of long delays, vague updates and ever-changing explanations, prosecutors said.
The months stretched into years. In many cases, car owners never see meaningful progress being made on their vehicles.
When customers demanded answers, Finley provided false status updates about parts, schedules or work in progress, authorities said. Evidence presented during the trial showed that not only were promised upgrades not completed, but parts were allegedly removed from customer vehicles and sold elsewhere.
Victims testified that the engine replacement they paid for was never performed.
Nearly a million dollars in losses
Investigators with the Galveston County Sheriff’s Office and the county’s Auto Crime Task Force began reviewing the complaints and uncovered what prosecutors say was a systemic operation.
According to court findings, more than $498,000 was stolen from the victims over a five-year period. Authorities recovered more than 20 classic vehicles during the investigation and returned them to their rightful owners.
While the total dollar amount may not rival some high-profile corporate fraud cases, the human impact is significant. Many of the vehicles involved were long-term projects or deeply personal investments, and owners lost their cars or the money they paid for them.
Finley was found guilty in December and sentenced to 60 years in prison.
Restoring the world
The case adds to a growing list of restoration shop fraud convictions across the country.
Last November, a New York restoration shop owner was sentenced to two years in prison for misrepresenting work done and lying about acquisitions to obtain payments from customers. Prosecutors said the fraud amounted to more than $2.5 million in this case.
The differences in sentencing highlight how courts weigh factors beyond monetary amounts. The number of victims in the Texas case was much higher, 72, compared to three in the New York case.
Federal authorities have warned in previous cases that recovery fraud can be especially difficult for customers to detect. Classic cars often take years to build, creating a gray area where delays can seem normal. Clients often rely on progress updates and reassurances rather than regular in-person inspections.
This dynamic can create opportunities for abuse.
Why recovery fraud persists
It costs little to restore or modify a classic vehicle. Engine swaps, fabrication work, paint and drivetrain upgrades can quickly climb into the five-figure range. Shops often require large deposits to cover parts and labor commitments.
The model works when it’s legal. When misused, financial losses can quickly mount.
The Texas case shows that repeated advances, extended timelines and a lack of transparency can allow misconduct to continue for years before law enforcement intervenes.
For enthusiasts, it’s a reminder that due diligence is important – written contracts, milestone-based payments, regular documentation and verified progress can reduce risk.
Harsh Sentences and Messages
A 60-year prison sentence is an unusually serious outcome in an auto fraud case. While parole eligibility and other legal factors may affect the actual time served, the sentence itself sends a strong message about how seriously local authorities take the case.
Classic car culture is built on trust between manufacturers and owners, buyers and sellers, collectors and craftsmen.
When this trust is exploited, the consequences can be long-lasting.
In this case, the court’s decision makes it clear that a recovery fraud involving dozens of victims will not be considered a minor commercial dispute. It will be considered a major criminal offence.
For collectors and enthusiasts, this is another cautionary tale of what happens when passion meets misplaced trust.
Join our newsletter, follow our Instagram page and connect with us on Facebook.