-
Red Lobster once blamed its failure on its blockbuster Endless Shrimp deal.
-
Now, the all-you-can-eat promotion is back, but with a different vibe.
-
Some customers were concerned that the value wasn’t the same and that the deal wasn’t driving traffic like before.
The Endless Shrimp is back – but it’s not causing a stampede.
On a recent night at a Red Lobster restaurant in Los Angeles, a steady stream of diners ordered all-you-can-eat combos, making the restaurant busier than usual. However, much of the restaurant was empty, and the pace was never as chaotic as servers remembered from past promotions.
“It’s popular,” one waiter said, “but not as popular as I thought it would be.”
It’s a remarkable, sometimes overwhelming, shift for a deal that once defined the brand.
Red Lobster has relaunched its Endless Shrimp restaurant in Los Angeles with limited availability for six weeks, servers said, reviving a promotion it said it couldn’t sustain. CEO Damola Adamolekun told Business Insider last year that he had “no plans” to bring the deal back after the company cited it as a key factor in its 2024 bankruptcy.
Now, at a time when its business needs a boost, Red Lobster says it’s reviving the Endless Shrimp to meet customer demand.
New data points to a more modest economic recovery.
Traffic data from Advan shows Red Lobster saw a significant spike in visits during the launch of its Endless Shrimp campaign in 2023, when the company first made the promotion a permanent menu item. The change hasn’t been seen since it was removed from the menu in 2024 or 2025, and it’s not as noticeable this time around. Traffic at the latest Endless Shrimp dropped 0.9% in the week, Advan data showed, well below the previous surge and down from the positive trend seen in March.
Traffic has been uneven lately, according to Placer.ai’s analysis. Last summer, Adamolekun saw a five-month spike in visits after it launched the chain’s viral seafood boil, but visits have declined every year since November 2025. Placer did not have available data on the performance of the relaunched Endless Shrimp restaurants as of press time.
RJ Hottovy, director of analytical research at Placer, said the chain’s 2026 results were impacted by “adverse weather, higher gasoline prices and broader macroeconomic concerns.” He added that the shrimp promotion “should resonate with value-conscious consumers” but that it was done in a softer, less predictable environment.
Casual dining chains like Red Lobster are trying to win back customers in a tougher environment than a decade ago. The industry is moving toward a K-shaped economy, in which upper-income diners are still spending, but lower- and middle-income consumers — the long-time mainstay of chains like Red Lobster — are scaling back or reducing their spending.
That’s putting pressure on higher-priced traditional brands, especially as competitors like Chili’s tend to favor great deals and aggressively market cheaper options. For Red Lobster, which typically charges more than many of its casual-dining peers, this dynamic makes it harder for diners to believe they’re getting a deal — even with an “endless” menu.
Two former Red Lobster executives told Business Insider that Endless Shrimp works best as a tightly controlled seasonal promotion — one that’s rare enough to feel like an event and strategically timed to fill the off-season.
Over time, they said, the company became increasingly reliant on it to drive traffic, eroding the sense of urgency that once made it so effective.
“It lost its appeal,” said one former executive.
This shift is not only reflected in the data, but also in the restaurants.
Some customers come to buy endless shrimp. Jeffrey Turney, a diner in Los Angeles, told Business Insider that he goes to Red Lobster every few months during the sale and is “excited” about the return of the bottomless deal, enthusiastically texting friends about it while waiting for his meal.
After dinner, he told Business Insider that overall the meal was “pretty good,” but that he “really didn’t like” the new Marry Me Shrimp, a social media flavor introduced last week.
About a third of diners at the Los Angeles restaurant took advantage of the deal during a recent dinner service, a server told Business Insider.
Most people skipped the bottomless shrimp, and some opted for a different deal — like Wednesday night’s $30 steak and lobster special, which has the same price tag as the L.A. market’s bottomless shrimp sale.
“I love that they’re bringing it back,” said social media creator and Red Lobster fan Destiny Howard, who runs the “Munch with Des” account, adding that the move shows the company is “listening to its customers.” She describes appeal in terms of responsiveness and novelty, not necessarily value.
For some diners, that number doesn’t make sense. Since restaurants charge between $24.99 and $29.99 for an all-you-can-eat five-course meal, depending on the location, some don’t think it’s a particularly good deal – especially when compared to other menu options in the same price range.
“I’m not happy with the price increase,” Turney said. “I think for $30, you should buy at least two sides,” he added, but noted that prices for groceries and dining out have increased across the board.
That sentiment is consistent with broader industry pressures: Seafood costs are rising and casual dining chains are increasingly competing on value with fast-food and fast-casual brands.
Endless shrimp has never just been cheap seafood. Former executives told Business Insider that this was an effort to lure people in during slow sales periods, preferably by ordering higher-margin products.
Today, while the promotions are bringing some diners in, it’s unclear whether they can bring the same boost. For Red Lobster, that may not be the point.
The chain runs Endless Shrimp late in its fiscal year and during a typically slower period, a window of modest increase in traffic.
As one former executive put it, a promotion can still be used as a lever to “move the business quickly,” even if it no longer has the same magic.
For customers like Turney, the comeback isn’t as impressive as it once was. He said he wouldn’t return to film “The Endless Shrimp” – but he’d be willing to try something else.
Read the original article on Business Insider